Nissan X-Trail vs Toyota RAV4: Ultimate SUV Showdown
If there ever were two SUVs deserving of a head-to-head comparison, it would be the Nissan X-Trail vs Toyota RAV4. When it comes to SUVs, Nissan and Toyota, two Japanese titans, often stand toe-to-toe. The Nissan X-Trail, now in its fourth generation, is a seasoned contender with a legacy spanning over two decades.
With its V-motion grille, the X-Trail unmistakably breathes the spirit of Nissan while the Toyota RAV4 remains an embodiment of Toyota’s commitment to rugged reliability and style. It seems the age-old rivalry continues with the Nissan X-Trail vying for dominance against Toyota’s RAV4 as Nissan always says, good competition is healthy!
Let’s take a closer look at the top-spec offerings and see how they measure up, starting with this handy comparison table.
| Feature | Nissan X-Trail 2.5 Acenta Plus 4WD | Toyota RAV4 2.5 VX AWD |
|---|---|---|
| Engine | 4-cyl, 2.5-litre petrol | 4-cyl, 2.5-litre petrol |
| Power/Torque | 135 kW/244 Nm | 152 kW/243 Nm |
| Gearbox | CVT | 8-Speed Automatic |
| Seats | 7 | 5 |
| Airbags | 8 | 5 |
| Kerb weight | 1,666 kg | 1,645-1,685 kg |
| Boot capacity | 485-litres | 733-litres |
| Fuel capacity | 55-litres | 55-litres |
| Claimed consumption* | 7.8 L/100 km | 7.3 L/100 km |
| Service plan & Warranty | 3-yr / 90,000 km, 6 years / 150,000 km | 6 Services / 90,000 km, 3 years / 100,000 km |
| Price | R759,900* | R809,600* |
Interior Main Features
Nissan X-Trail: Stepping inside the X-Trail is a testament to its design evolution. Rear doors open up to 85 degrees for seamless access. Whether you opt for a five-seat or seven-seat variant, it provides 16 different load configurations. Adding to the comfort, the X-Trail boasts USB ports both in the front and rear, three-zone air-conditioning, and three displays, ensuring that drivers are well-informed and connected.
Toyota RAV4: The RAV4 does not skimp on comfort and convenience. Its spacious interior exudes a sense of premium SUV luxury. The abundance of rear legroom and a vast 733-litre boot capacity makes it an ideal choice for family trips. Technologically, the RAV4 is well-equipped with features like a keyless push-button start, heated front seats, a wireless phone charger, and a plethora of multimedia options.
Exterior Main Features
Nissan X-Trail: Embodying Nissan’s signature style, the X-Trail boasts the V-Motion grill, LED headlights, and pronounced front air vents. Its distinctive box shape design promises ample interior space. Those looking for a touch of personalisation can choose from a range of optional accessories, from hood deflectors to glossy black air intake finishers.
Toyota RAV4: This vehicle has a sense of robust elegance. Its angular and planted design, combined with its sturdy build, gives it a commanding presence on the road. Offering both style and practicality, the RAV4 comes equipped with features like LED headlights, fog lights, and more.
Engine And Fuel Consumption
Both the X-Trail and RAV4 feature 4-cylinder, 2.5-litre petrol engines. The RAV4 edges out slightly in power at 152 kW as compared to X-Trail’s 135 kW, but the torque figures are nearly identical. Fuel consumption favours the RAV4 at 7.3 L/100 km, against X-Trail’s 7.8 L/100 km (keeping in mind the X-Trail is a 7-seater, while the RAV4 is a 5-seater). While the X-Trail’s CVT gearbox provides a smooth ride, the RAV4’s 8-Speed Automatic gearbox also offers engaging performance.
Nissan X-Trail vs Toyota RAV4 Safety Features
Safety remains paramount for both brands. The X-Trail, graced with a five-star safety rating by the ANCAP, offers a comprehensive suite of safety features, from blind spot warnings to ProPILOT. On the other hand, the RAV4 ensures passenger safety with a wealth of technology including adaptive cruise control, a pre-crash protection system, and seven airbags.
Nissan X-Trail Safety and Driver Convenience Features
- Airbags (Driver, Passenger, Curtain, Front Side, Front far side)
- Anti-lock braking system (ABS)
- Electronic brake-force distribution (EBD)
- Brake Assist System (BAS)
- Hill Start Assist (HSA) and Hill Descent Control
- Vehicle Dynamic Control (VDC)
- Reverse Camera
- Forward Emergency Braking with junction assist & pedestrian/cyclist detection
- Lane Departure Warning incl. Lane Departure Prevention
- Intelligent Lane Intervention and Lane Keep Assist (LKA)
- Around View Monitor + Moving Object Detection (Trim-level dependant)
- Blind Spot Intervention (Trim-level dependant)
- Predictive Front Collision Warning
- ProPILOT
- Driver Attention Alert
- Electric Parking Brake incl. Auto Hold (Trim-level dependant)
Toyota RAV4 Safety and Driver Convenience Features
- Airbags (Side, Curtain, Driver, Passenger and Driver Knee)
- Anti-Theft System (Immobiliser Alarm, Double lock)
- Auto Door Lock
- Child Lock and Child Restraint System (ISOFIX)
- Emergency Brake Signal
- Electric Parking Brake
- Front Seat Belts with Pretensioner Force Limiter
- Pre-Crash System (Brake Synchronised)
- Rear Seat Belts
- Park Distance Control
- Anti-Lock Braking System (ABS)
- Blind Spot Monitor (BSM) standard with Rear Cross Traffic Alert
- Brake Assist (BA)
- Electronic Brake Force Distribution (EBD)
- Hill Assist Control (HAC)
- Multi-Terrain Select (MTS)
- Vehicle Stability Control (VSC)
- Drive Mode Select (Standard Eco, Normal, Sport)
- Trailer Sway Control (TSC)
- Downhill Assist Control (DAC)
- Lane Keeping System
Models And Price Range
The X-Trail comes in three variants: Visia CVT, Acenta CVT, and Acenta Plus CVT, with a hybrid model on the horizon. In contrast, while there are more RAV4 models, this analysis focuses on the top-spec Toyota RAV4 2.5 VX AWD to compare to the X-Trail’s 2.5L version. As for pricing, the X-Trail is slightly more pocket-friendly at R759,900, compared to the RAV4’s R809,600*.
From the Critics
The new X-Trail … “With improvements and enhancements across the board, it makes this popular Nissan a more usable SUV for modern families. It’s a solid evolution, … which is exactly what buyers are looking for.” (WhichCar)
The Toyota RAV4 … “Medium-sized family SUVs require ample space for passengers and luggage, as well as a small measure of off-road ability. Fair styling is of lesser importance, but there are some pretty smart-looking SUVs in this segment.” (AutoTrader)
Conclusion: Nissan X-Trail vs Toyota RAV4
The Nissan X-Trail and Toyota RAV4 are both impressive in their own rights. The choice boils down to personal preferences and priorities. In this game of Titans, there’s no wrong decision. Remember, we’re merely presenting the facts; the road you take is entirely up to you. Safe driving!
* Pricing accurate at the time of writing, August 2023
